
Originally Posted by
bq97
"Keep in mind that the fuse, fusible link, circuit breaker, etc. has to be located right at the source to be effective.”
That’s not correct. Yes, it is.The protection device can be anywhere in the circuit. No, it can't.At the speed electricity travels a few hundred feet is insignificant. That has nothing to do with it. If this was the case the circuit breaker or fuse box in your house would be spread out over the entire home and the fuses in the car would not be centrally located. You just made my point. A fusible link or fuse element is normally at the beginning of the circuit in order to protect the entire circuit not just part of it. Exactly what I said. Stated another way, if your fusible link was on the load end of the circuit, how would the wiring be protected if the wire grounded to the chassis?
“A common misconception is that its function is to protect the device on the circuit. Instead, it is a safety feature designed to protect the wiring and prevent a fire.”
It actually does both depending on the protection device selected and where the fault is generated. To use your home wiring analogy, the fuses in the fuse box protect the wiring, and the radio's fuse protects the radio. An electrician wiring your home has little knowledge of what will be connected to most circuits and it's not his concern.If the radio shorts internally the fuse blows to protect the rest of the circuit. Any overcurrent event blows the fuse to protect the wiring, if that's what you mean by the rest of the circuit, so I think we're just restating the same thing over and over. If there is a high current situation somewhere else in the wiring the fuse might blow as the electricity follows the least resistive path thus saving the radio’s internals. No. If some other device on the same circuit, such as a motor, drew excess current, it might cause a drop in voltage but would not cause more current to flow to the radio.That’s why household fuses might blow and circuit breakers trip in a close lightning strike. They blow when their designed current limit is exceeded, whatever the cause, but they're not designed for lightning protection, which is a high voltage event. I wouldn't count on them to protect that radio.
”Because most of the car's individual circuits are protected by fast blowing fuses, fusible links rarely carry out their function. For instance, if your heater's blower motor siezes, a 15 amp fuse will blow, and the 14 gauge fusible link will not be damaged in the least.”
A fusible link is rarely used to protect a single circuit in the manor a fuse is. Right. In my example the fusible link supplies the fuse block, which protects the individual circuits such as the blower motor. They are generally used to protect a number of fused and un-fused circuits from an over-current situation. True.Also, auto fuses are far from being fast blowing. Sure they are, especially when compared to fusible links.
“saw fusible links under the hood of another car in little cartridge form and they read in amps.”
The little cartridge things are fuse elements. Fuse elements are generally for higher amperage circuits 30 -100 amps and are color coded depending on rating.
For Jordan:
Drawing power from the positive post on the battery, the stud on the starter solenoid, or the hot studs on the fuse block is immaterial; electrically it is the same place as each one connects to the other. Keep in mind these physical locations are all un-switched. The length of wiring alone will not prevent voltage spikes. The only way to prevent spikes from getting into the ECU is add a protection circuit but if the ECU was designed for a car it should have its own internal protection. I’m just an Electrical Engineer not a fuel injection guru so you may want to talk to a fuel injection guy about internal protection.
Brian
Bookmarks