The Classic Opel Forums  

Go Back   The Classic Opel Forums > Performance and Racing > Performance > Opel Engine Performance Modifications
Home Opel Groups Calendar Members Map FAQ eBay Search

Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 03-07-2009   #1 (permalink)
Opeler
 
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: stokesdale NC
Posts: 12
lee33lyn is on a distinguished road
Unanswered: what kind of horsepower?

looking at turning a 1.9 into a road racer. What kind of horsepower could I get out of it without turbocharging it.
thanks Leebo
lee33lyn is offline  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in Technorati
Reply With Quote Top home
Old 03-07-2009   #2 (permalink)
Supercharged 2.4
 
Gumby's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: Oregon
Posts: 619
Gumby is on a distinguished road
Originally Posted by lee33lyn View Post
looking at turning a 1.9 into a road racer. What kind of horsepower could I get out of it without turbocharging it.
thanks Leebo
How much money are you looking to spend? Do your rules say you have to stick with the 1.9l engine?
__________________
1972 Opel GT: 2.4, big brakes, efi - inprogress
Gumby is offline  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in Technorati
Reply With Quote Top home


Old 03-07-2009   #3 (permalink)
1000 Post Club
 
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: Milner, GA.
Posts: 1,701
Logbook Entries: 12
Real Name: Dan
wrench459 is on a distinguished road
Provided Answers: 2
Garage
Originally Posted by Gumby View Post
How much money are you looking to spend?
You can go only as fast as your wallet allows. To put it another way.
I'm seeing three inch long intake runners with ITB's would or could be a nice setup.
It all about the rules your running under.
wrench459 is offline  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in Technorati
Reply With Quote Top home


Old 03-08-2009   #4 (permalink)
GT Racing
 
SantaClaw's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: Kirkenes North of Norway
Posts: 98
Real Name: Andreas. H
SantaClaw is on a distinguished road
Provided Answers: 1
Originally Posted by lee33lyn View Post
looking at turning a 1.9 into a road racer. What kind of horsepower could I get out of it without turbocharging it.
thanks Leebo


Ok, the 1.9 isn't the best starting point for a high horsepower non turbo engine...

1st of all, it's not a crossflow engine, secondly, it's not to tuning friendly... and finally, it's heavy...

If you want a screamer of a road racer, your best, and cheapest bet is the 2 liter 16v Opel\Vauxhall engine, called 20XE\C20XE

This comes stock with 150 bhp, and with just a set of new cams, and throttlebodies(or dual carbs) will output around 200 bhp, with a lot less weight than the stock 1.9...

For you to get close to 200 bhp in the 1.9, will require parts that costs 2-3x more than a stock 16v...


Specifically, you need the following parts to fit a 20XE engine:

1. Opel Manta 1.8 oil pan.
2. C20XE with Distributor less ignition, or a regular C20XE, but you need to make room for the Distributor in the firewall.
3. Opel Manta 1.8 engine mounts..
4. Opel Manta 1.8 clutch bell housing..
5. Custom headers, I can get you prefabricated headers that will fit the GT.

This will put you back around 1700$-2500$ depending on the engine type, and whether or not you go for the headers + the cost of the throttlebodies/carburettors and camshafts..

Getting close to 200 bhp in a 1.9, will set you back at least 3000-4500$

And another thing, the Torque and HP curves of the C20XE annihilates the 1.9...


I'm currently building a C20NE based screamer in my GT, that's a OHC 2 liter 8v engine, with an aluminum head...

Costing around 9600$ !! It will put out around 250 bhp when done, built for sustained 8500 rpm ++ use.....


Don't believe me regarding the costs ?

1. Porting\machining the head, large valves ++, www.cncheads.co.uk : 1557$
2. Block machining/mounting oil jets to cool the pistons : 400$
3. Custom forged oversize pistons : 778$
4. Custom forged con rods with forced cross pin lubrication: 700$
5. Balanced and lightened 2.2 liter crank: 737$
6. Bearings and high flow oil pump: 500$
7. Lightened flywheel: 550$
8. Throttlebodies: 1700$
9. Electromotive Tech 3, 1700$ including sensors ++
10. Mechanical valve lifters, and camshaft + crank pulleys (Crank pulley is aluminum and smaller size due to high rpm) : 1800$

+fuel system +oil cooler +water injection +headers +exhaust ++++

+ a LOT of other costs... BUT, the end result should be fun...

Last edited by tekenaar; 03-08-2009 at 12:43 PM. Reason: spesifically?
SantaClaw is offline  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in Technorati
Reply With Quote Top home


Old 03-08-2009   #5 (permalink)
Opeler
 
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: stokesdale NC
Posts: 12
lee33lyn is on a distinguished road
as long as I stay with a opel engine that came in the car I won't have any problems. If they think I have too much power then they will make me get the car dyno'd and then they use a weight verses horsepower ratio. I'd like to get close to 200 horsepower if possible and keep the car close 2000lbs.I'm familiar with other cars but this is my first opel.To verify,any opel engine will work in the car. If it came with a 1.9 I can use a 2.4 without any problems ,but I have 2 1.9 engines.As far a budget,I don't like to waste money but racing can be an expensive hobby so I know its gonna cost.I'd like to bullit proof the block and then I could swap out the top end as I made more money.
thanks Lee
lee33lyn is offline  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in Technorati
Reply With Quote Top home


Old 03-08-2009   #6 (permalink)
Opeler
 
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: stokesdale NC
Posts: 12
lee33lyn is on a distinguished road
Santaclaw might have a plan.How hard are C20xe to find and what cars did they come in?
thanks Lee
lee33lyn is offline  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in Technorati
Reply With Quote Top home


Old 03-08-2009   #7 (permalink)
GT Racing
 
SantaClaw's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: Kirkenes North of Norway
Posts: 98
Real Name: Andreas. H
SantaClaw is on a distinguished road
Provided Answers: 1
Originally Posted by lee33lyn View Post
Santaclaw might have a plan.How hard are C20xe to find and what cars did they come in?
thanks Lee
They came in the Opel Kadett GSI 16v/Vauxhall Astra MKI 16v , the Opel/Vauxhall Calibra the Opel Vectra/Vauxhall Cavalier, Also came in the Opel Astra GSI 16v.

Not difficult at all to find, over seas... contact any scrap dealer in the UK, Germany, Norway\Sweden +++ and they are almost certain to have one..

I'm able to get one for around 1200$..

I see engines with all the parts you need for a older Opel RWD conversion go for around 1800$

The C20XE have more power stock, than any stock 4 Cyl CIH with an added weight reduction bonus, it blitzes the 2.4, with more torque, and a lot more bhp over wider bands...

I'd think you would do fine with a stock C20XE to begin with...


BTW the US company http://www.importperformanceparts.net/ have complete tuning kits for this engine and stock parts for rebuilding, but the camshafts\throttlebodies should be bought via other dealers, like www.dbilas.de www.enem.se or www.rissemotorsport.de

Last edited by SantaClaw; 03-08-2009 at 09:51 AM. Reason: added parts information
SantaClaw is offline  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in Technorati
Reply With Quote Top home


Old 03-08-2009   #8 (permalink)
ggl
Opeler
 
ggl's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: Norway
Posts: 64
ggl is on a distinguished road
Provided Answers: 1
While it's always nice to have a competitive package from the beginning there's a lot to be said for starting out with something a little more "basic" to get you feet wet and get a feeling for what's needed without spending a fortune, not to mention months in the garage just to get the car running

I would start out with one of your 1.9's in a mild tune and plan for something a little better, either something based on a CIH engine since they bolt straight into whatever you already have or something a little more out there like one of the more modern C20 engines which will obviously take a little more effort on the planning side

Too many projects have been sitting in garages all over the world because their owners started out a little over-ambitious
__________________
"The nice thing about standards is that you have so many to choose from"

--Andy Tanenbaum--
ggl is offline  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in Technorati
Reply With Quote Top home


Old 03-08-2009   #9 (permalink)
former opel racer
 
jeff denton's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2002
Location: near some glaciers
Posts: 2,863
Real Name: Jeff "Oh-Oh" Denton
jeff denton is on a distinguished road
Provided Answers: 4
Originally Posted by SantaClaw View Post

Not difficult at all to find, over seas... contact any scrap dealer in the UK, Germany, Norway\Sweden +++ and they are almost certain to have one..

I'm able to get one for around 1200$..


I'd think you would do fine with a stock C20XE to begin with...
If there was such thing as a C20 being available in this country we would all be going this route, obviously. A 2.2 CIH shortblock core alone costs $700 here. It's all about the shipping. Same thing in a 1.9 can be had for free, ask me how I know this! (thanks again to my dear friends at gt.com)

Very few Opelers are going to go ten grand for an engine. You might as well order up the Risse crate motor.
I'll have a little over two thou into the next one, the 2.2, because I can re-use a lot of custom 1.9 stuff I've already invested in. All I need is the crank, custom pistons/rings/pins, Eagle rods, some bearings and a couple gaskets. A little machine shop work too, of course. And I'll have the 150 hp easily, who knows how much more? Will I have your 200 hp? I don't know.

I'm going with 2.2 stroke because the experts keep telling me it is so radically superior in terms of power available, not so much just the few extra cubic inches of displacement, but the longer stroke gives the possibility of building in some more compression ratio. You just can not get that with a 1.9 stroke, best you can do is about 11 to one but the piston dome is huge.

I can do this because my car will race at a track where this kind of modification is allowed and encouraged. Thus it would be stupid to show up with a 1.9. Think about this, Lee. Do you want to just race, or be competitive? There is a big difference.

Hope this helps.
__________________

No Opels were harmed in the filming of this movie.
However two Mustangs, a Pinto, and a Capri were hospitalized.
One Mustang was euthanized the next morning.

Last edited by jeff denton; 03-08-2009 at 12:54 PM.
jeff denton is offline  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in Technorati
Reply With Quote Top home


Old 03-08-2009   #10 (permalink)
Opeler
 
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: stokesdale NC
Posts: 12
lee33lyn is on a distinguished road
Can I get the 2.2 stroke out of my 1.9 block?Shipping is expensive in the states ,I'd hate to see what it would be overseas for a engine!I don't want to be a back marker that's for sure. I just try to be smart with my money for the horsepower gain.
lee33lyn is offline  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in Technorati
Reply With Quote Top home


Old 03-08-2009   #11 (permalink)
Project 1450 supporter...
 
RallyBob's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2002
Location: Pleasant Valley, CT
Posts: 7,452
Real Name: Bob Legere
RallyBob has a spectacular aura aboutRallyBob has a spectacular aura about
Provided Answers: 20
Garage
Originally Posted by lee33lyn View Post
looking at turning a 1.9 into a road racer. What kind of horsepower could I get out of it without turbocharging it.
thanks Leebo
Sanctioning body? Classification?

These are the most critical questions here. If it's an SCCA class then you'll HAVE to stick with the 1.9 litre CIH engine as a foundation, and can't even entertain any of the newer engines (e.g.... twincam, crossflow, larger displacement, etc).

But in SCCA's most 'open' class that allows the Opel to run in (GT-lite), the highest HP cars were a tad over 200 hp. With the now-required air restrictors, that number drops by about 30 hp.
__________________
My Flickr photos.
Jan. 3, 1984 - Jan. 3, 2009, that's 25 years of this damn Opelitis!
C.R.L. 9/22/69 - 12/8/99, J.M.L. 3/3/43 - 6/15/04
RallyBob is offline  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in Technorati
Reply With Quote Top home


Old 03-08-2009   #12 (permalink)
Project 1450 supporter...
 
RallyBob's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2002
Location: Pleasant Valley, CT
Posts: 7,452
Real Name: Bob Legere
RallyBob has a spectacular aura aboutRallyBob has a spectacular aura about
Provided Answers: 20
Garage
Originally Posted by SantaClaw View Post
Ok, the 1.9 isn't the best starting point for a high horsepower non turbo engine...

1st of all, it's not a crossflow engine, secondly, it's not to tuning friendly... and finally, it's heavy...
Interestingly, the C20XE is not as light as most think! Someone on the Hecktriebler forum weighed a complete CIH engine with inlet/exhaust manifolds, and a complete C20LET (admittedly with turbo attached), and the weight was surprising.

C20LET = 162kg (356.4 lbs)
2.0 litre CIH = 153kg (336.6 lbs)

Figuring the turbo weighs 15 lbs/6.8 kg...it is still slightly heavier!

No denying the C20XE has more tuning potential and far greater aftermarket support however.

Bob
__________________
My Flickr photos.
Jan. 3, 1984 - Jan. 3, 2009, that's 25 years of this damn Opelitis!
C.R.L. 9/22/69 - 12/8/99, J.M.L. 3/3/43 - 6/15/04
RallyBob is offline  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in Technorati
Reply With Quote Top home


Old 03-08-2009   #13 (permalink)
Opeler
 
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: stokesdale NC
Posts: 12
lee33lyn is on a distinguished road
I'm gonna run Nasa, time trials for awhile and then in the GTS wheel to wheel.It might be two years before I get to GTS.
lee33lyn is offline  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in Technorati
Reply With Quote Top home


Old 03-08-2009   #14 (permalink)
former opel racer
 
jeff denton's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2002
Location: near some glaciers
Posts: 2,863
Real Name: Jeff "Oh-Oh" Denton
jeff denton is on a distinguished road
Provided Answers: 4
Originally Posted by lee33lyn View Post
Can I get the 2.2 stroke out of my 1.9 block?Shipping is expensive in the states ,I'd hate to see what it would be overseas for a engine!I don't want to be a back marker that's for sure. I just try to be smart with my money for the horsepower gain.
Yes, you are now considering exactly what I am planning. Here's the glitch: 2.2 cranks are (as far as I can tell) just about IMPOSSIBLE to buy in the US. I have been offered plenty of them from Europe. Shipping makes it outrageous. A crank shop recommended by members here can weld up and stroke a 1.9 crank for about $500. OGTS will sell us a 2.2 short block CORE for $700. I really don't NEED the block, the rods are garbage, don't want to use stock pistons. I just need the crank.
Which way would you go?
Study up on roller rockers, too. If you figure out how to get some, let me know!
__________________

No Opels were harmed in the filming of this movie.
However two Mustangs, a Pinto, and a Capri were hospitalized.
One Mustang was euthanized the next morning.
jeff denton is offline  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in Technorati
Reply With Quote Top home


Old 03-08-2009   #15 (permalink)
Project 1450 supporter...
 
RallyBob's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2002
Location: Pleasant Valley, CT
Posts: 7,452
Real Name: Bob Legere
RallyBob has a spectacular aura aboutRallyBob has a spectacular aura about
Provided Answers: 20
Garage
Originally Posted by lee33lyn View Post
I'm gonna run Nasa, time trials for awhile and then in the GTS wheel to wheel.It might be two years before I get to GTS.
Gotcha. I'm prepping a Manta for NASA GTS Challenge as well, although it's gonna be turbocharged. Much more leniancy with NASA!
__________________
My Flickr photos.
Jan. 3, 1984 - Jan. 3, 2009, that's 25 years of this damn Opelitis!
C.R.L. 9/22/69 - 12/8/99, J.M.L. 3/3/43 - 6/15/04
RallyBob is offline  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in Technorati
Reply With Quote Top home


Old 03-08-2009   #16 (permalink)
Project 1450 supporter...
 
RallyBob's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2002
Location: Pleasant Valley, CT
Posts: 7,452
Real Name: Bob Legere
RallyBob has a spectacular aura aboutRallyBob has a spectacular aura about
Provided Answers: 20
Garage
Originally Posted by jeff denton View Post
Yes, you are now considering exactly what I am planning. Here's the glitch: 2.2 cranks are (as far as I can tell) just about IMPOSSIBLE to buy in the US. I have been offered plenty of them from Europe. Shipping makes it outrageous. A crank shop recommended by members here can weld up and stroke a 1.9 crank for about $500. OGTS will sell us a 2.2 short block CORE for $700. I really don't NEED the block, the rods are garbage, don't want to use stock pistons. I just need the crank.
Which way would you go?
Study up on roller rockers, too. If you figure out how to get some, let me know!
I'd get the full 2.2 then. It has a cast-in 95 mm bore. So you can easily punch them out to 97 mm. Get aftermarket long rods, forged pistons, and use the 2.2 crank. 2291 cc's!

Or offset grind the 2.2 crank, use 'intermediate' rods with smaller journals, and get a 2.4 litre bored/stroked engine. With MUCH less rotating mass than a factory 2.4.
__________________
My Flickr photos.
Jan. 3, 1984 - Jan. 3, 2009, that's 25 years of this damn Opelitis!
C.R.L. 9/22/69 - 12/8/99, J.M.L. 3/3/43 - 6/15/04
RallyBob is offline  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in Technorati
Reply With Quote Top home


Old 03-08-2009   #17 (permalink)
former opel racer
 
jeff denton's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2002
Location: near some glaciers
Posts: 2,863
Real Name: Jeff "Oh-Oh" Denton
jeff denton is on a distinguished road
Provided Answers: 4
Ah. Thanks, Bob. So I DO want the 2.2 block. It was my understanding that a 1.9 block could go to 96mm okay.
Yes, plan would be to dummy up the 2.2 crank in any block with Roger's Crower 5.5" rods and Venolia pistons (all from last 1.9+) and figure out piston cd problem, maybe fixable with next piston having less cd, also thicker head gasket (which I have to research more yet). I know nothing until the dummy up gives me numbers.
Or, as you say, from there fix all this with better, lighter, yet slightly shorter rods (the Eagle Toyota rod) and offset grind more stroke in the 2.2 crank. See what piston cd comes up as with or without thick gasket and get on the phone with Ross Pistons again.
Whatever, I gotta do something, stalling is not an option anymore because benefactors to the plan of racing the Opel again have cut the checks. I have to spend their money now. OGTS has some crating and shipping to do Monday morning. Thanks again, Bob, I have to learn Opel power all over again now that we have abandoned the 1.9.
__________________

No Opels were harmed in the filming of this movie.
However two Mustangs, a Pinto, and a Capri were hospitalized.
One Mustang was euthanized the next morning.
jeff denton is offline  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in Technorati
Reply With Quote Top home


Old 03-08-2009   #18 (permalink)
ggl
Opeler
 
ggl's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: Norway
Posts: 64
ggl is on a distinguished road
Provided Answers: 1
Originally Posted by RallyBob View Post
Interestingly, the C20XE is not as light as most think! Someone on the Hecktriebler forum weighed a complete CIH engine with inlet/exhaust manifolds, and a complete C20LET (admittedly with turbo attached), and the weight was surprising.

C20LET = 162kg (356.4 lbs)
2.0 litre CIH = 153kg (336.6 lbs)

Figuring the turbo weighs 15 lbs/6.8 kg...it is still slightly heavier!

No denying the C20XE has more tuning potential and far greater aftermarket support however.

Bob
That *is* interesting I too just assumed the C20 engines were lighter, I wonder why this is, taller block due to the longer stroke as well as thicker cylider walls perhaps ?
__________________
"The nice thing about standards is that you have so many to choose from"

--Andy Tanenbaum--
ggl is offline  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in Technorati
Reply With Quote Top home


Old 03-09-2009   #19 (permalink)
GT Racing
 
SantaClaw's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: Kirkenes North of Norway
Posts: 98
Real Name: Andreas. H
SantaClaw is on a distinguished road
Provided Answers: 1
Originally Posted by ggl View Post
That *is* interesting I too just assumed the C20 engines were lighter, I wonder why this is, taller block due to the longer stroke as well as thicker cylider walls perhaps ?
The "C20 engines"...
The C is only an emission standard. So the C20NE has a catalytic converter, newer electronics, a lambda probe, gasoline gas recycling... The 20NE doesn't...


First of all...

There's the

C20NE (115 bhp 170 nm) CR 9.2-1 Camshaft: 262 degrees Cat converter.
20NE (116 bhp 175 nm) CR 9.2-1 Camshaft: 262 degrees
20SE (122 bhp 175 nm) CR 10.1-1 Camshaft: 262 degrees
20SEH (130 bhp 180 nm) CR 10.1-1 Camshaft: 268 degrees
(came stock with oil cooler)

All are 86x86mm(bore/stroke) 1998cc 8Valve OHC engines, with aluminum heads, all are identical, except for engine management, and the parts listed above, also a cam belt failure isn't an issue on these as the valves cannot touch the pistons....

They cost, (in Norway) anything from 350$ for a c20ne to around 500$ for a really good 20SEH (they are getting rare)


Then there's the:

C20XE(150 bhp) (costs around 1100$)
20XE(156 bhp No Cat) (Costs around 12-1300$)
and
C20LET (costs about 4000$ for a running engine)
(turbo version with Cat)

They also have 86x86mm(bore/stroke) 1998cc, but with 16valves and DOHC, all came stock with oil coolers, but should the cam belt fail, you've got 16 bent valves.....

Early versions of the 20XE came with stock forged pistons and a balanced crank..

The C20LET is in some ways a different engine than the C20XE\20XE, with a different generation of engine management, different pistons (Forged Mahle), different con rods, different flywheel, small differences in the block, and different camshafts.

Other differences: the 16v heads can crack, if it cracks, it can be repaired (most doesn't crack), you can also get it reinforced in advance...

There is three different versions of these heads out there:

1. GM head, can crack, has better flow than the rest.
2. Coscast head, (made by cosworth) is indestructible, less flow than the other two, but is most sought after because it's easy to identify by an extra tab on it's side...
3. GM reinforced head, doesn't crack, has better flow than the Coscast head..

Here are some weighs by Opel:

C20LET 145kg 1998cc 16v turbo engine 204 bhp - 280 nm
(Awesome engine, but overkill for the GT, there are chip tuning kits for this engine producing 430 bhp and 420foot pounds)

C20XE 136 kg. 1998cc 16v engine 150 bhp - 198 nm

C20NE 133 kg. 1998cc 8v engine, 115bhp - 170 nm


C30SE 240 kg. CIH 3 liter 24v straight six.. 204 bhp - 280 nm

2.2i CIH weighs in at 156 kg... 115 bhp - 185 nm
Notice 156 kg for the 2.2, that's without fluids..

The 20E OHC/DOHC family of engines, all have aluminum heads, making them lighter...

Ok, here's the important info, notice the torque & bhp on the C20NE 8v engine, then compare it to the 2.2i....

Hm.. both have 115 bhp, but the 2.2 got 15 nm more than the C20NE...

But it also weighs 23 kg more, Also the C20NE has better torque and bhp curves than the 2.2, proving that more is sometimes less...

In theory the 2.2-2.4 have more bhp than the C20NE 8v, but in practice, the C20NE, is more tuning friendly, and is of a newer design making the torque and bhp curves better...


A 2.4 might outrun a C20ne in a straight line, but it won't be by much...

A 2.2 doesn't stand a chance...

There are NO 4 cyl CIH engines that have any chance of outrunning a C20XE/20XE


In addition, there's the "newer" Ecotec family of engines...

The C20XEV - Z20XEV - Z22XE +++
Those took over for the C20NE\C20XE's and are completely crap, with reduced flow in the heads, weaker constructions ++++
Steer clear !

So what I'm saying is: The 20E OHC/DOHC family of engines, will be a better choice, every time... over a CIH... Due to beter design, better durability(larger oil ducts in the head, oil pan baffle ++), less weight, better tuning potential, cheaper parts...

But... as far as originality goes.... or vintage... The CIH's certainly have an edge.. if you use the stock 1.9 cam cover, and modify the 1.9 inlet you can make a 2.4 look virtually stock...

Last edited by SantaClaw; 03-09-2009 at 04:55 AM.
SantaClaw is offline  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in Technorati
Reply With Quote Top home


Old 03-09-2009   #20 (permalink)
Opeler
 
Join Date: Aug 2008
Location: England, leyland
Posts: 77
lamchop77 is on a distinguished road
I'll chuck this one into the discussion!!! I race Autograss in the uk, Opel Kadett coupe with a 2.2 CIH. New engine in the build at the moment but thats a different story. The 2.2 motor ran std pistons, l&b std bottom end, 2.0 ported head 46/41 valves, 244 Kent cam,std manifold and Dellorto 48's.

The motor was dyno'd at 180 bhp. I've raced against 2.0xe with TB's cammed up and could beat them pretty comfortably. One guy had a full blown race (SBD) 2.1 and the 2.2 had more grunt off the bend and held its own to the next corner. The xe's are a good motor BUT i think that the CIH is totally underated. The motor i put together cost around £1800 which i think is pretty reasonable.

HTH

Chris
lamchop77 is offline  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in Technorati
Reply With Quote Top home


Old 03-09-2009   #21 (permalink)
Member
 
Hiro's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: Paris, France, EEC.
Posts: 942
Hiro
Originally Posted by SantaClaw View Post
The C20XE have more power stock, than any stock 4 Cyl CIH with an added weight reduction bonus, it blitzes the 2.4, with more torque, and a lot more bhp over wider bands...

the C20XE is a very good engine design but it is not lighter than a CIH,
moreover it has a quite crappy rod ratio (1.66) & piston speed reaches the 20m/s limit at only 7000rpm.

this means the stock setup/parts can not be used for a very high output engine,
lots of Opel racers have experienced severe piston/rod failures when trying to rev this engine too high with std parts.

now if you put real race parts in this engine it's another story:
it is frequenly used in single seaters reaching 250-280hp @ 9500-10000rpm without any problem,
but the usual cost of such a race engine is around 12000 to 15000 euros.

summary about this C20XE 2.0 DOHC: keep it near stock or rob a bank!
whereas a very good 2.5 CIH will cost about 3000 euros for a bullet-proof 200hp version,
with much more torque than a std C20XE & no pain to fit under the hood...
JMTCW,
Hiro
Hiro is offline  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in Technorati
Reply With Quote Top home


Old 03-09-2009   #22 (permalink)
Member
 
Hiro's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: Paris, France, EEC.
Posts: 942
Hiro
Originally Posted by jeff denton View Post
Yes, you are now considering exactly what I am planning. Here's the glitch: 2.2 cranks are (as far as I can tell) just about IMPOSSIBLE to buy in the US. I have been offered plenty of them from Europe. Shipping makes it outrageous. A crank shop recommended by members here can weld up and stroke a 1.9 crank for about $500. OGTS will sell us a 2.2 short block CORE for $700. I really don't NEED the block, the rods are garbage, don't want to use stock pistons. I just need the crank.
Which way would you go?
Study up on roller rockers, too. If you figure out how to get some, let me know!
is there any way we could make a shipment deal with OGT?
someone on this side of the pond could coordinate collecting the various cranks & centralize them,
but another person has to take in charge the shipment issue...
Hiro
Hiro is offline  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in Technorati
Reply With Quote Top home


Old 03-09-2009   #23 (permalink)
Member
 
Hiro's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: Paris, France, EEC.
Posts: 942
Hiro
Originally Posted by ggl View Post
That *is* interesting I too just assumed the C20 engines were lighter, I wonder why this is, taller block due to the longer stroke as well as thicker cylider walls perhaps ?
there are two block castings for the OHC/DOHC engines:
the small one (1.2/1.3/1.6) is much lighter than a CIH,
the big one (other 1.6 type/1.8/2.0) is still lighter than the CIH but not so much.
now the 2.0 DOHC is a big block casting & the head is much heavier than the OHC head in spite of its aly material.
I guess it's because there are 2 camshafts/16 valves etc etc,
I've observed the same thing comparing the 6 cyl CIH cast iron head to the 24 valve DOHC aly head.
Hiro
Hiro is offline  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in Technorati
Reply With Quote Top home


Old 03-09-2009   #24 (permalink)
Member
 
Hiro's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: Paris, France, EEC.
Posts: 942
Hiro
Originally Posted by SantaClaw View Post
The "C20 engines"...
The C is only an emission standard. So the C20NE has a catalytic converter, newer electronics, a lambda probe, gasoline gas recycling... The 20NE doesn't...


First of all...

There's the

C20NE (115 bhp 170 nm) CR 9.2-1 Camshaft: 262 degrees Cat converter.
20NE (116 bhp 175 nm) CR 9.2-1 Camshaft: 262 degrees
20SE (122 bhp 175 nm) CR 10.1-1 Camshaft: 262 degrees
20SEH (130 bhp 180 nm) CR 10.1-1 Camshaft: 268 degrees
(came stock with oil cooler)

All are 86x86mm(bore/stroke) 1998cc 8Valve OHC engines, with aluminum heads, all are identical, except for engine management, and the parts listed above, also a cam belt failure isn't an issue on these as the valves cannot touch the pistons....

They cost, (in Norway) anything from 350$ for a c20ne to around 500$ for a really good 20SEH (they are getting rare)


Then there's the:

C20XE(150 bhp) (costs around 1100$)
20XE(156 bhp No Cat) (Costs around 12-1300$)
and
C20LET (costs about 4000$ for a running engine)
(turbo version with Cat)

They also have 86x86mm(bore/stroke) 1998cc, but with 16valves and DOHC, all came stock with oil coolers, but should the cam belt fail, you've got 16 bent valves.....

Early versions of the 20XE came with stock forged pistons and a balanced crank..

The C20LET is in some ways a different engine than the C20XE\20XE, with a different generation of engine management, different pistons (Forged Mahle), different con rods, different flywheel, small differences in the block, and different camshafts.

Other differences: the 16v heads can crack, if it cracks, it can be repaired (most doesn't crack), you can also get it reinforced in advance...

There is three different versions of these heads out there:

1. GM head, can crack, has better flow than the rest.
2. Coscast head, (made by cosworth) is indestructible, less flow than the other two, but is most sought after because it's easy to identify by an extra tab on it's side...
3. GM reinforced head, doesn't crack, has better flow than the Coscast head..

Here are some weighs by Opel:

C20LET 145kg 1998cc 16v turbo engine 204 bhp - 280 nm
(Awesome engine, but overkill for the GT, there are chip tuning kits for this engine producing 430 bhp and 420foot pounds)

C20XE 136 kg. 1998cc 16v engine 150 bhp - 198 nm

C20NE 133 kg. 1998cc 8v engine, 115bhp - 170 nm


C30SE 240 kg. CIH 3 liter 24v straight six.. 204 bhp - 280 nm

2.2i CIH weighs in at 156 kg... 115 bhp - 185 nm
Notice 156 kg for the 2.2, that's without fluids..

The 20E OHC/DOHC family of engines, all have aluminum heads, making them lighter...

Ok, here's the important info, notice the torque & bhp on the C20NE 8v engine, then compare it to the 2.2i....

Hm.. both have 115 bhp, but the 2.2 got 15 nm more than the C20NE...

But it also weighs 23 kg more, Also the C20NE has better torque and bhp curves than the 2.2, proving that more is sometimes less...

In theory the 2.2-2.4 have more bhp than the C20NE 8v, but in practice, the C20NE, is more tuning friendly, and is of a newer design making the torque and bhp curves better...


A 2.4 might outrun a C20ne in a straight line, but it won't be by much...

A 2.2 doesn't stand a chance...

There are NO 4 cyl CIH engines that have any chance of outrunning a C20XE/20XE


In addition, there's the "newer" Ecotec family of engines...

The C20XEV - Z20XEV - Z22XE +++
Those took over for the C20NE\C20XE's and are completely crap, with reduced flow in the heads, weaker constructions ++++
Steer clear !

So what I'm saying is: The 20E OHC/DOHC family of engines, will be a better choice, every time... over a CIH... Due to beter design, better durability(larger oil ducts in the head, oil pan baffle ++), less weight, better tuning potential, cheaper parts...

But... as far as originality goes.... or vintage... The CIH's certainly have an edge.. if you use the stock 1.9 cam cover, and modify the 1.9 inlet you can make a 2.4 look virtually stock...
none of my numerous CIH4 weight 156kg unless fitted with both inlet/exhaust manifolds
+ very heavy dual mass FW version + full clutch,
some 2.4 are fitted this way but we never use these heavy FW for any race/street applications.

a bare CIH4 weights about 120-130kg,
a bare CIH6 is about 180-190kg,
that's without ancillaries of course.

to give an idea about CIH4 parts weights (by memory):
empty block = about 50kg
empty head = about 23kg
cam/valves/cover etc = 10kg
crank = 20kg maxi
set of 4 piston+rod = about 6kg
crank damper = 2kg maxi
lower pan = another 3kg
FW = 10kg maxi
that's 124kg for a 2.4 without ancillaries.

Hiro
Hiro is offline  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in Technorati
Reply With Quote Top home


Old 03-09-2009   #25 (permalink)
Member
 
Hiro's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: Paris, France, EEC.
Posts: 942
Hiro
Originally Posted by lamchop77 View Post
I'll chuck this one into the discussion!!! I race Autograss in the uk, Opel Kadett coupe with a 2.2 CIH. New engine in the build at the moment but thats a different story. The 2.2 motor ran std pistons, l&b std bottom end, 2.0 ported head 46/41 valves, 244 Kent cam,std manifold and Dellorto 48's.

The motor was dyno'd at 180 bhp. I've raced against 2.0xe with TB's cammed up and could beat them pretty comfortably. One guy had a full blown race (SBD) 2.1 and the 2.2 had more grunt off the bend and held its own to the next corner. The xe's are a good motor BUT i think that the CIH is totally underated. The motor i put together cost around £1800 which i think is pretty reasonable.

HTH

Chris

same for us here Chris:
a friend of mine races a MantaB in "earth/dirt-rallye",
he's compared the 2.0 CIH with 2.0 OHC & DOHC (all stock engines):
he is quite disapointed by the 2.0 DOHC because torque @ mid-rpm is too low & the engine is heavier than he thought,
he thinks a mildly tuned 2.0 OHC is a better compromise in terms of money/weight/power band.
now another friend of mine has a "stage 1" race 2.0 DOHC in his Caterham,
a very lively & streetable 220hp version but a full 10000 euros investment...
Hiro
Hiro is offline  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in Technorati
Reply With Quote Top home


Reply

Bookmarks


Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
 
Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is Off
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On



All times are GMT -4. The time now is 08:10 AM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2009, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.3.0
Clubs, Garage Plus vBulletin Plugins by Drive Thru Online, Inc.
1998-2009 OpelGT.com - OpelGT .com is not affiliated with General Motors Corp. or it's Adam Opel Division.